Melatonin Myths: Why This Popular Sleep Aid Often Fails

Melatonin has become one of the most widely used sleep aids in the world. It’s sold over the counter in many countries and prescribed in others and used by millions hoping to fall asleep faster or fix a restless night. But despite its popularity, melatonin isn’t always the solution it appears to be.

While it can help reset the body clock, especially in cases like jet lag or irregular schedules, it rarely addresses the deeper reasons why many people struggle to sleep well—and often comes with limitations and unwanted effects.

In this article, we’ll explore what melatonin actually does (and doesn’t do), where it falls short, and why deeper, longer-lasting sleep requires a more holistic approach.

Melatonin: What It Is, How It Works, and Where It Falls Short

Melatonin is a hormone your brain’s pineal gland produces naturally. Its main job? To regulate your circadian rhythm, the internal clock that signals when it’s time to sleep and when to wake up. As evening approaches, melatonin levels rise, helping you wind down. By morning, those levels drop, making it easier to wake up and feel alert.

Unlike sleeping pills, melatonin doesn’t sedate you. Think of it as a biological nudge, a signal to your body that it’s time to rest and not a knockout switch.

When melatonin supplements can help:

• Resetting your body clock after long-haul travel (jet lag)
• Adjusting to night shifts or an irregular work schedule
• Short-term sleeplessness when your schedule is disrupted

Where melatonin falls short:
If your sleep issues involve waking up during the night, restless or shallow sleep, or an overactive mind at bedtime, melatonin often won’t solve the problem.

Here’s why:

• It doesn’t help you stay asleep
• It doesn’t make your sleep deeper
• Your body metabolises it quickly often within 30 minutes to 2 hours, meaning the resulting drop in melatonin can actually wake you up again

This is why many people who take melatonin still find themselves waking in the night or feeling unrefreshed the next day.

Melatonin supplements: known limitations and side effects

Melatonin is often described as “natural,” but most supplements are synthetically produced. And quality can vary dramatically between brands.

One study found that melatonin content varied by up to 347% compared to what was stated on the label raising serious concerns about dose accuracy and consistency.

Even a single dose of melatonin can lead to side effects in some people, including: Daytime grogginess: This can occur when melatonin is taken too late in the evening or in too high a dose, leading to residual levels remaining in the bloodstream by morning. While melatonin has a short half-life, extended-release forms or excessive intake can extend its effects into the waking hours.

Vivid dreams or disrupted sleep cycles: Melatonin can alter REM sleep architecture, potentially increasing dream intensity or frequency. In some individuals, this shift may lead to fragmented or less restorative sleep.

Headaches, dizziness, or restlessness: These symptoms may be linked to melatonin’s broader effects on neurotransmitters like serotonin and GABA, or from a misalignment between melatonin intake and the body’s internal circadian rhythm.

Long-term use of melatonin may also lead to a physiological dependence.

When melatonin is supplied externally over extended periods—particularly at high doses—your body may reduce its own natural production. Over time, this can make it harder to fall or stay asleep without supplementation, especially if the root causes of poor sleep aren’t addressed holistically.

Why deeper sleep requires more than melatonin

High-quality sleep is more than just falling asleep. It’s about reaching deep sleep stages, staying asleep through the night, and waking up feeling refreshed.

That process depends on a network of systems, including:

• The hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis is a system in the body that regulates the stress response and the release of the stress hormone cortisol. Typically, a low cortisol level is needed for falling asleep, and a sudden raise in cortisol makes us wake up.
• GABA, a calming neurotransmitter produced by the brain that slows brain activity. GABA plays a crucial role in preparing the body for sleep by reducing excitability
• Serotonin, a naturally occurring chemical in the body that acts as both a neurotransmitter and a hormone which influences mood. It is essential for the body to produce melatonin. Physical discomfort or tension, which can disrupt sleep continuity

Disruptions in any of these areas—whether from stress, low mood, or overstimulation—can make good sleep harder to achieve, even when melatonin levels are technically normal.

Better Sleep with AVEA Sereniser: Support Your Sleep without Melatonin

Rather than overriding your sleep system with external melatonin, the most effective approach is to support the processes that help your body sleep naturally. This includes:

• Supporting serotonin → melatonin conversion
• Calming the stress response
• Encouraging GABA activity for mental quiet
• Addressing physical restlessness or discomfort

That’s the idea behind AVEA’s Sereniser, a melatonin-free formula that works with your biology, not against it.

5 evidence-based habits to improve sleep naturally

Supplement support works best when combined with good sleep habits. Here are a few proven strategies:

1. Wind down consistently. Try stretching, journaling, or reading 30–60 minutes before bed.
2. Limit bright light exposure. Dim overhead lights, reduce screen time, or use blue light-blocking glasses in the evening.
3. Keep your sleep and wake times regular. This strengthens your circadian rhythm.
4. Avoid stimulants late in the day. That includes caffeine, alcohol, and heavy meals.
5. Keep your bedroom cool and dark. Aim for a temperature around 18–19°C to support deep sleep.

These simple changes can help reset your sleep system over time.

Final Thought: Why Better Sleep Isn’t About More Melatonin but Better Balance

Melatonin can help shift your sleep schedule, but it’s not a solution for the complex, root-level causes of poor sleep. Most people don’t need more melatonin. They need better internal balance.

Sereniser was created to support just that, by calming the nervous system, supporting serotonin and GABA activity, and encouraging natural melatonin production.

References

Foley, H. M., & Steel, A. E. (2019). Adverse events associated with oral administration of melatonin: A critical systematic review of clinical evidence. Complementary therapies in medicine, 42, 65–81. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctim.2018.11.003 

Gorfine, T., Assaf, Y., Goshen-Gottstein, Y., Yeshurun, Y., & Zisapel, N. (2006). Sleep-anticipating effects of melatonin in the human brain. NeuroImage, 31(1), 410–418. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2005.11.024 

Lopresti, A. L., Smith, S. J., Metse, A. P., & Drummond, P. D. (2022). A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial investigating the effects of an Ocimum tenuiflorum (Holy Basil) extract (HolixerTM) on stress, mood, and sleep in adults experiencing stress. Frontiers in nutrition, 9, 965130. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnut.2022.965130 

Pachikian, B. D., Copine, S., Suchareau, M., & Deldicque, L. (2021). Effects of Saffron Extract on Sleep Quality: A Randomized Double-Blind Controlled Clinical Trial. Nutrients, 13(5), 1473. https://doi.org/10.3390/nu13051473 

Pouchieu C, Pourtau L, Brossaud J, et al. Acute Effect of a Saffron Extract (Safr’InsideTM) and Its Main Volatile Compound on the Stress Response in Healthy Young Men: A Randomized, Double Blind, Placebo-Controlled, Crossover Study. Nutrients. 2023;15(13):2921. Published 2023 Jun 27. doi:10.3390/nu15132921

https://www.plthealth.com/product-catalog/serezin